The concept that phototoxic chemicals can be identified in chemical ri
sk assessments by computing the energy difference between highest occu
pied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (HOMO-LUMO gap) was eval
uated using two new sets of phototoxicity data from the recent literat
ure. The original model, developed from data with unsubstituted PAH to
xicity to Daphnia magna, showed that phototoxicity was observed when t
he HOMO-LUMO gap varied between 6.7 and 7.5 eV. All substituted alpha-
terthienyls that were phototoxic to mosquito larvae and to brine shrim
p had HOMO-LUMO gap energies within the 7.1 +/- 0.4 eV ''phototoxicity
window''. The alpha-terthienyls within this range that did not exhibi
t phototoxicity contained carboxyl or other polar substituents,which l
ikely prevented bioaccumulation in the organisms. Polyamino and polyni
tro derivatives of toluene in munitions wastes were reported to be pho
totoxic to sea urchins even though the HOMO-LUMO gap energies exceeded
8.0 eV. Because the same toluenes were not phototoxic to D. magna nor
to Escherichia coli, we suggest that the developmental effects observ
ed in the sea urchins were caused by electrophilic species from metabo
lic activation rather than the production of oxygen radicals from phot
o induced excited states of the molecules.