White Pelicans Pelecanus onocrotalus foraging at Lake Nakuru, Kenya, s
pent most of their time in flocks of two to several tens of individual
s, and most flocks adopted a synchronized fishing behaviour. However,
the maximum capture rate when feeding was attained by solitary individ
uals, and it decreased non-linearly as flock size increased. Individua
ls in non-synchronized flocks had a higher capture rate than those in
synchronized flocks of the same size. The total number of bill probes
decreased with the size of synchronized flocks, but this reduction in
foraging costs did not compensate for the decrease in capture rate, si
nce the ratio of successful probes to total probes did not increase wi
th flock size. We discuss some hypotheses that might explain the parad
oxical result that most White Pelicans aggregate into flocks and synch
ronize their behaviour and yet they attain a lower capture rate than t
hose foraging alone.