Zz. Wang et al., ACOUSTIC-WAVE PROPAGATION IN THE SOLAR ATMOSPHERE .1. REDISCUSSION OFTHE LINEARIZED THEORY INCLUDING NONSTATIONARY SOLUTIONS, The Astrophysical journal, 444(2), 1995, pp. 879-915
The normal dispersion analysis for linear adiabatic wave propagation i
n stratified atmospheres adopts a real frequency and solves for the co
mplex vertical wavenumber. We show that an exponentially stratified at
mosphere does not have any spatially bounded normal modes for real fre
quencies. The usual treatment involves a representation where the imag
inary part of the vertical wavenumber yields a rho(-1/2) dependence of
the velocity amplitude which diverges as \z\ --> infinity. This solut
ion includes a cutoff frequency below which acoustic modes cannot prop
agate. The standard dispersion analysis is a local representation of t
he wave behavior in both space and time but which is assumed to repres
ent the motion throughout -infinity < t < infinity and 0 < z < infinit
y. However, any solution which has a purely sinusoidal time dependence
extends through this full domain and is divergent due to the rho(-1/2
) dependence. We show that a proper description is in terms of a near
field of a boundary piston which is driven arbitrarily as a function o
f space and time. The atmosphere which responds to this piston is a se
mi-infinite layer which has an initially constant sound speed but whic
h has the usual gravitational stratification. In a restricted domain o
f space and time above this boundary, the wavelike behavior of the med
ium may be described by frequencies and vertical wavenumbers which are
both complex. When both parameters are allowed to have imaginary comp
onents, a new range of solutions is found for which there is virtually
no cutoff frequency. We show that vertical energy propagation can tak
e place through the solar atmosphere as a result of oscillations below
the nominal cutoff frequency. Previously, the largest amplitude oscil
lations which generally have low frequencies were dropped from the cal
culation of energy flux because their frequencies are below the cutoff
frequency. This new family of near-held waves permits these modes to
carry energy vertically outward and raises the possibility that the la
rgest amplitude 5 minute oscillations play a substantial role in the t
ransport of acoustic energy to the chromosphere.