One hundred forty-two patients (66 men and 76 women) from 20 autosomal
-dominant pedigrees and 3 families including 5 ''sporadic'' cases were
examined. A great similarity of clinical manifestations among those a
ffected was noted. Clinical variability of phenotypes reflecting vario
us phases of the disease and different expressions of the mutant gene
were always within the limits of the identical final phenotype of the
disease, namely the facio-scapulo-humero-peroneal-femoro (posterior gr
oup of the muscles)-gluteal (gluteus maximus). Thus, the clinically an
d genetically homogeneous group of patients with autosomal-dominant de
scending with a ''jump'' form of facioscapulohumeral dystrophy (FSHD),
called facioscapuloperoneal dystrophy (FSPD), was examined. Among the
observed cases we did not come across any having the autosomal-domina
nt gradually descending form of FSHD, called facioscapulolimb dystroph
y (FSLD), in which the pelvic and proximal lower limb muscles get weak
earlier than in the peroneal group (anterior tibial) muscles. We coul
d not reveal the ''pure'' facioscapulohumeral phenotype of muscle weak
ness in 142 examined patients. A ''pure'' FSHD does not exist as a nos
ological entity. If represents only the syndrome which characterizes t
he initial phase of FSLD, but not of the FSPD. It is quite probable th
at FSPD and FSLD which may be differentiated clinically are two differ
ent diseases connected with the mutation of allelic or even different
genes. Linkage studies in FSPD and FSLD mapping genes would confirm th
is data. (C) 1995 John Wiley and Sons, Inc.