Rh (rhesus) D is the dominant antigen of the ph blood group system. Re
cent advances in characterization of the nucleotide sequence of the cD
NA(s) encoding the Rh D polypeptide allow the determination of the Rh
D genotype at the DNA level. This can be of help in cases in which red
blood cells are not available for phenotyping, eg, when it concerns a
fetus. We have tested three independent DNA typing methods based on t
he polymerase chain reaction [PCR) for their suitability to determine
the Rh D genotype. DNA derived from peripheral blood mononuclear cells
from 234 Rh-phenotyped healthy donors (178 Rh D positive and 56 Rh D
negative) was used in the PCR. The Rh D genotypes, as determined with
a method based on the allele-specific amplification of the 3' noncodin
g region of the Rh D gene described by Bennett et al (N Engl J Med 329
:607, 1993), were not concordant with the serologically established ph
enotypes in all cases. We have encountered 5 discrepant results, ie, 3
false-positive and 2 false-negative (a father and child). ph D genoty
ping with the second method was performed by PCR amplification of exon
7 of the D gene with allele-specific primers. In all donors phenotype
d as D positive tested so far (n = 178), the results of molecular geno
typing with this method were concordant with the serologic results, wh
ereas a false-positive result was obtained in one of the D-negative do
nors (also false-positive in the first method). Complete agreement was
found between genotypes determined in the third method, based on a 60
0-bp deletion in intron 4 of the Rh D gene described by Arce et al (Bl
ood 82:651, 1993), and serologically determined phenotypes. The Rh blo
od group system is complex, and unknown polymorphisms at the DNA level
are expected to exist. Therefore, although genotypes determined by th
e method of Arce et al were in agreement with serotypes, it cannot yet
be regarded as the golden standard. More experience with this or othe
r methods is still needed. (C) 1995 by The American Society of Hematol
ogy.