The object of this study was to find out whether an arthrotomy of the
knee would damage joint proprioception. Twenty patients who underwent
arthrotomy, and 20 patients after arthroscopy, were tested on a modifi
ed ergometer and the electromyographic action of their quadriceps and
hamstrings recorded The quadriceps action started later and had a shor
ter duration (20 ms) after arthrotomy. The differences are statistical
ly significant in intra-individual comparison both for vastus laterali
s and medialis, in comparison with the normal group for only the vastu
s medialis. There were no significant differences in muscle control af
ter arthroscopy. These results are in favour of preferring arthroscopy
to arthrotomy whenever possible.