A. Sygula et Pw. Rabideau, STRUCTURE AND INVERSION BARRIERS OF CORANNULENE, ITS DIANION AND TETRAANION - AN AB-INITIO STUDY, Journal of molecular structure. Theochem, 333(3), 1995, pp. 215-226
Ab initio calculations were performed for neutral corannulene (1) and
its dianion and tetraanion. The minimum energy conformations, as well
as the transition states for bowl-to-bowl inversion, were located and
characterized by calculation of vibrational frequencies. For some char
ged species, the Hartree-Fock method predicts critical point symmetrie
s that are lower than those deduced from Huckel theory. However, inclu
sion of electron correlation effects shows this to be an artifact of t
he HF method. Consideration of electron correlation is also crucial fo
r the estimation of the inversion barriers, while the quality of the b
asis set has only moderate impact on these results. The ''best theoret
ical estimate'' of the barriers decreases from 14.2 kcal mol(-1) for n
eutral 1, to 7.9-9.2 kcal mol(-1) for the dianions, and to 3.2 kcal mo
l(-1) for the tetraanion. While the introduction of negative charges i
nto corannulene causes overall flattening of its curvature, even in th
e most extreme case - the tetraanion - preference for a bowl-shaped ge
ometry remains. Within C-5v symmetry, the (3)A(2) triplet state is cle
arly favored over the (1)A(1) and (1)E(2) Singlet states of the isolat
ed dianion. However, no significant preference of the triplet vs. sing
let electronic state emerges if the symmetry of the molecular framewor
k of the dianion is allowed to distort. Finally, analysis of the charg
e distribution in the tetraanion 5 does not support the ''anion within
a trianion'' model for the tetraanion of corannulene.