Hjc. Devries et al., REDUCED WOUND CONTRACTION AND SCAR FORMATION IN PUNCH BIOPSY WOUNDS -NATIVE COLLAGEN DERMAL SUBSTITUTES - A CLINICAL-STUDY, British journal of dermatology, 132(5), 1995, pp. 690-697
In full-thickness skin wounds dermal regeneration usually fails, resul
ting in scar formation and wound contraction. We studied dermal regene
ration by implantation of collagenous matrices in a human punch biopsy
wound model. Matrices were made of native bovine collagen I fibres, a
nd either hyaluronic acid, fibronectin, or elastin was added. Matrices
were placed in 6-mm punch biopsy holes in seven patients (biopsies we
re used for the grafting of leg ulcers), and covered with a protective
semi-permeable polyether urethane membrane. Histology, wound contract
ion and dermal architecture were studied. Dermal architecture was eval
uated using a recently developed laser scatter technique. All collagen
matrices showed a tendency to reduce wound contraction, compared with
control wounds; elastin- and fibronectin-treated matrices showed sign
ificantly less contraction than control wounds. Only the addition of e
lastin had a clear beneficial effect on dermal architecture; collagen
bundles were more randomly organized, compared with control wounds, an
d wounds treated with collagen matrices coated with fibronectin or hya
luronic acid, or without coating. We conclude that the punch biopsy wo
und model provides important information on dermal regeneration in hum
ans, Native collagen matrices with elastin contributed to dermal regen
eration and reduced wound contraction, in contrast with matrices coate
d with fibronectin or hyaluronic acid, or without coating. Future clin
ical studies of large-area, full-thickness wounds will be required to
establish their clinical relevance for leg ulcer and burn treatment.