Pj. Vandermeer et al., DEFINING CANOPY GAPS IN A TROPICAL RAIN-FOREST - EFFECTS ON GAP SIZE AND TURNOVER TIME, Acta oecologica, 15(6), 1994, pp. 701-714
The effects of different gap definitions on gap size and concomitant c
hanges in turnover time were investigated. In a tropical rain forest i
n French Guiana, 18 canopy gaps were measured using 3 different gap de
finitions. Gap size was significantly affected by gap definitions. Str
ong positive correlations were found between gap sizes according to th
e different definitions. Based on one of these linear relations, effec
ts of gap definitions on turnover time calculations were evaluated. It
was found that in the studied forest, the turnover time at the forest
floor is much lower (some 4 to 8 times) than the turnover time at the
forest canopy. It is concluded that it is doubtful whether it is vali
d to compare gap- and turnover time studies which have been carried ou
t so far. To be able to make valid comparisons between different studi
es on forest dynamics in the future, it is important to reach a consen
sus on the choice and application of one or more clearly defined gap d
efinitions.