Jp. Callaghan et Sm. Mcgill, MUSCLE-ACTIVITY AND LOW-BACK LOADS UNDER EXTERNAL SHEAR AND COMPRESSIVE LOADING, Spine (Philadelphia, Pa. 1976), 20(9), 1995, pp. 992-998
Study Design. This study analyzed anatomic and neural control characte
ristics of the trunk musculature. Subjects were exposed to external sh
ear and compressive toads with equivalent moments to evaluate activati
on patterns and loading on the low back. Objectives. The migration of
activity between the thoracic and lumbar erector spinae muscle groups
was examined to determine whether the motor control system chooses to
minimize joint loading by recognizing differences in moment, compressi
on, and shear support requirements and assigning muscle activation in
the most appropriate way. Summary of Background Data. Loads were appli
ed either parallel or perpendicular to the low back to create compress
ive or shear forces. No previous study has attempted to isolate the re
sponse of the trunk musculature with the type of external load. Method
s. Eleven male subjects isometrically held an external load that was a
ltered to create either a compressive or an anterior shear load on the
low back but with equal extensor (reaction) moments (experiment 1). I
n a second experiment four men repeated the task with an increased ran
ge of applied loads (5-25 kg) together with measurements of intra-abdo
minal pressure. Results. The tasks with a compressive external load re
sulted in significantly higher levels of activation for all seven elec
tromyographic channels recorded. Intra-abdominal pressure, compressive
and shear joint forces were all higher in the compression loading met
hod when equal loads and low back moments were compared. Conclusions.
It was concluded that the motor control system does not arrange muscle
activation levels in a way to minimize lumbar spinal loading at least
for the relatively low levels of this study. Biomechanical models tha
t use the objective criterion of minimum joint load may not be represe
ntative of the motor control system, at least in the low back.