Jl. Gagliardi et al., SEEING AND KNOWING - KNOWLEDGE ATTRIBUTION VERSUS STIMULUS-CONTROL INADULT HUMANS (HOMO-SAPIENS), Journal of comparative psychology, 109(2), 1995, pp. 107-114
Interest in cognition in nonhuman animals has inspired new approaches
to discovering animals' ability to attribute knowledge to others (e.g.
, D. J. Povinelli, K. E. Nelson, and S. T. Boysen, 1990). The assumpti
ons of such experiments were tested in this study by training a group
of humans (Home sapiens) to use accurate information provided by a con
federate who was watching as 1 container among 4 was baited; a 2nd gro
up was similarly trained to use accurate information provided by a con
federate whose back was turned during baiting. On a single reversal tr
ial, the roles of the 2 confederates were switched. Subjects were able
to learn their respective tasks but attended to different aspects of
the confederates, as revealed by the reversal trial. Although attribut
ional interpretations can be applied to such data, many of the choices
in this experiment can be explained more readily with the basic princ
iples of contingency-based learning.