S. Chen et al., RETINOIC ACID RECEPTOR-GAMMA MEDIATES TOPICAL RETINOID EFFICACY AND IRRITATION IN ANIMAL-MODELS, Journal of investigative dermatology, 104(5), 1995, pp. 779-783
Among retinoic acid receptors (RARs) alpha, beta, and gamma, the messe
nger RNA level of RAR-gamma is the most readily detectable by Northern
blotting in human and mouse skin. This observation suggests that RAR-
gamma may play a critical role in the modulation of the therapeutic be
nefits and side effects of retinoids in skin. To test this hypothesis,
11 RAR-gamma selective retinoids were synthesized based on three rela
ted structures. Each compound was found to prefer RAR-gamma when asses
sed by retinoid-induced transcriptional activity (RAR-gamma > RAR-beta
> RAR-alpha). The apparent Kd for binding to recombinant receptor pro
tein was found to follow a similar trend. To correlate this receptor s
electivity with in vivo activity, the compounds were tested topically
in the Rhino mouse utriculi reduction and rabbit irritation models, tw
o assays widely used to screen retinoids for efficacy and side effects
, respectively. The results indicated that for these compounds, both e
fficacy in the utriculi reduction assay and irritation potential in ra
bbits correlated positively with the RAR-gamma transactivation activit
y, with r(2) of 0.9 and 0.8, respectively. These data suggest that RAR
-gamma is an important regulator of retinoic acid efficacy in skin and
further, that the irritation associated with the use of retinoids is
most likely a receptor-mediated process.