Rd. Coursey et al., INDIVIDUAL PSYCHOTHERAPY AND PERSONS WITH SERIOUS MENTAL-ILLNESS - THE CLIENTS PERSPECTIVE, Schizophrenia bulletin, 21(2), 1995, pp. 283-301
The perspectives of persons with serious mental illness about their ex
periences with individual psychotherapy were obtained from a stratifie
d random sample of 12 psychosocial rehabilitation centers from all cen
ters in Maryland. Response and completion rates, test-retest reliabili
ty, and generalization data were positive. Eight areas were explored:
(1) Utilization and duration: of the 212 respondents, 90 percent had b
een in therapy for a median of 12 months (mean = 3 years); only a thir
d expected to end their therapy within 5 years. (2) Therapeutic effect
iveness: most of the respondents (72%) reported that individual psycho
therapy had brought positive changes to their lives, 14 percent report
ed negative changes, and 14 percent reported that therapy had had no e
ffect. (3) Preferred interventions and parameters: sixteen percent fel
t that medication was most useful, 25 percent felt that talking therap
y was most useful, and 60 percent endorsed a combination of the two. W
ith respect to diagnosis and psychotherapy, 84 percent of respondents
with schizophrenia preferred brief, less frequent sessions of reality-
oriented therapy over longer, more frequent sessions of insight therap
y. Respondents with bipolar and major depression were equally split be
tween the two. (4) Therapeutic issues: human concerns were more freque
ntly rated as important and were rated higher in importance than illne
ss-specific symptoms. (5) Clients' view of illness: Only 8 percent tho
ught their illness was a brain disease, a third thought it was a psych
ological problem, and a quarter thought it was a combination of both;
a third answered, ''I don't know.'' Almost half did not know what thei
r therapists thought. (6) Therapeutic relationship: Friendliness was t
he quality most desired in a therapist. (7) Confidentiality: Most felt
that therapists generally kept the clients' confidences. (8) Empowerm
ent: Persons who felt empowered in therapy spent less time in hospital
s, expected a shorter stay in therapy, and knew more about their probl
ems. Suggestions are made about a more client-responsive model of indi
vidual psychotherapy for persons with serious mental illness.