Y. Bilu et E. Witztum, BETWEEN SACRED AND MEDICAL REALITIES - CULTURALLY SENSITIVE THERAPY WITH JEWISH ULTRA-ORTHODOX PATIENTS, Science in context, 8(1), 1995, pp. 159-173
One disconcerting aspect of the role of culture in shaping human suffe
ring is the gap between the explanatory models of therapists and patie
nts in multicultural settings. This gap is particularly noted in worki
ng with Jewish ultra-Orthodox psychiatric patients whose idioms of dis
tress are often derived from a sacred reality not easily reconcilable
with psychomedical reality. To meet the challenge to therapeutic effic
acy that this incompatibility may pose, we propose a culturally sensit
ive therapy based on strategic principles that focus on the patient's
mythic world and religious idioms of distress as the kernel of therape
utic interventions. Using one case of post-traumatic stress disorder (
PTSD) as illustration, we seek to show how the religious symbols throu
gh which the patient's distress was articulated may be manipulated to
effect cure. The case highlights the narrative quality of both illness
construction and self-reconstruction.