We examine the question of economic voting in the major industrial dem
ocracies. Using pooled time series data for 17 nations from 1960 to 19
87, we argue that the magnitude and nature of the relationship between
economic conditions and the vote depends upon the level of welfare st
ate development. We find that (a) in countries with low to moderate le
vels of welfare spending, the economy has a more dramatic effect on th
e vote when things are good than when things are bad, and (b) the econ
omy plays less of a role in states with high levels of spending, regar
dless of the direction of economic change. The implications for voting
behavior, democratic accountability, and welfare policy are discussed
.