Two different methods for skin dose calculations, VARSKIN Mod 2 and PS
S are compared for a spherical uranium fuel particle (diameter 1-500 m
u m) deposited on the skin. Nuclide specific beta dose rate at differe
nt skin depths for a particle of unit activity is determined as a func
tion of particle size. Both methods show that the effects of self-shie
lding must be included in the dose calculations for low and medium ene
rgy beta emitters. Skin dose rate is drastically overestimated when po
int source approximation is used. For high energy beta emitters (e.g.,
Y-90, Rh-106, and Pr-144) the volume source can be approximated as a
point source. The difference in doses is then below 20% for particles
up to 100 mu m in diameter. The models give equal results deep in the
skin (in terms of range of the beta particles). The reason is that the
correction due to the diminished backscattering in air-tissue interfa
ce is insignificant at large distances. For three-dimensional sources
the backscattering correction should be introduced in the VARSKIN Mod
2.