T. Andreae et Hj. Bandelt, PERFORMANCE GUARANTEES FOR APPROXIMATION ALGORITHMS DEPENDING ON PARAMETRIZED TRIANGLE INEQUALITIES, SIAM journal on discrete mathematics, 8(1), 1995, pp. 1-16
The worst-case analyses of heuristics in combinatorial optimization ar
e often far too pessimistic when confronted with performance on real-w
orld problems. One approach to partially overcome this discrepancy is
to resort to average-case analyses by stipulating realistic distributi
ons of input data. Another way is to incorporate a priori information
on the potential domain of the input data, for instance, assuming the
triangle inequality for input matrices is in some cases instrumental f
or establishing approximation algorithms with fixed performance guaran
tee. Now, a parametrized form of the triangle inequality has a conside
rably larger range of applicability and allows the prediction of the h
euristics performance, where otherwise no bound could be provided. For
example, it is interesting to observe that two well-known approximati
on algorithms for the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), assuming the t
riangle inequality, behave differently when one relaxes the imposed tr
iangle inequality. The double-spanning-tree heuristic can be adjusted
(by suitably extracting a Hamilton circuit from a Eulerian walk) to yi
eld an approximation algorithm with performance guarantee increasing q
uadratically with the parameter governing the relaxed triangle inequal
ity. The Christofides algorithm cannot be modified in this way and hen
ce does not tolerate a relaxation of the standard triangle inequality
without loosing the bound ori its relative performance.