In this article, we study the optimal regulation of a dominant firm wh
en an unregulated firm actively competes. Generally, the existence of
an active rival imposes new and binding constraints on regulatory prob
lems. We characterize optimal policies both when demands are known (co
mplete information) and unknown (incomplete information) to the regula
tor. Optimal policies under complete information may set the price at
the dominant firm above or below its marginal cost. Optimal policies u
nder incomplete information may be either pooling or separating, const
ant over a range of the prior distribution of the firm's private infor
mation, and leave no information rent to the firm.