Dj. Torgerson et Ja. Kanis, COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PREVENTING HIP-FRACTURES IN THE ELDERLY POPULATION USING VITAMIN-D AND CALCIUM, Quarterly Journal of Medicine, 88(2), 1995, pp. 135-139
Recent evidence suggests that vitamin D and calcium can reduce the inc
idence of hip fracture amongst elderly women. We estimated the costs o
f using either parenteral vitamin D alone, or oral vitamin D plus calc
ium, in a number of treatment strategies. These were: all women in a c
ommunity setting; women with low body mass index (BMI) in the communit
y; women in nursing homes; women with low BMI in nursing homes. The co
st per averted fracture amongst women living in the community through
the use of parenteral vitamin D alone was pound 946, and the cost per
averted hip fracture was pound 2317. Inclusion of calcium significantl
y increased the cost to pound 14 240 for any fracture and pound 22 379
for hip fractures. However, targeting either treatment on women with
the lowest BMI reduced the cost of averting a hip fracture, as did tar
geting women living in nursing homes. After removing cost savings from
treatment costs, savings to the NHS occurred for all parenteral vitam
in D strategies but only one of the oral vitamin D and calcium strateg
ies. Preventing fractures with injectable vitamin D is likely to produ
ce savings for the NHS. The addition of calcium will increase costs si
gnificantly, unless the intervention is targeted on those at high risk
.