F. Mesple et al., SOME DIFFICULTIES IN MODELING CHLOROPHYLL-A EVOLUTION IN A HIGH-RATE ALGAL POND ECOSYSTEM, Ecological modelling, 78(1-2), 1995, pp. 25-36
The High Rate Algal Pond (HRAP) is an efficient treatment for controll
ing wastewater pollution by reducing the organic matter and the inorga
nic nutrient content. Deterministic modelling of temporal evolution of
algae could provide a rational basis for pond management. An experime
ntal HRAP was set up in Meze (France) and sampled weekly over 24 month
s. Models simulating the evolution of chlorophyll a concentration and
nutrients (N and P) were constructed using Stella II software. The sea
sonal pattern of chlorophyll a concentrations results from the annual
cycle of solar irradiance and temperature, whereas shorter trends (1 t
o 4 weeks) are dependent on the evolution of zooplankton groups. The f
irst difficulty is to determine the functional relationships of the ph
ytoplankton and zooplankton groups. In the model the evolution of the
phytoplankton taxa is considered to be dependent on (i) inherent param
eters of phytoplankton taxa (mortality rate, growth rate, saturating l
ight intensity, etc.) and on (ii) parameters of zooplankton taxa (filt
ration rate, size selectivity, etc.). To take all these taxa as state
variables, and all the associated parameters, into account is impossib
le: to solve such a problem, we forced the evolution of the biomass of
the phytoplankton and zooplankton taxa. This approach improves the ag
reement between the simulated and observed chlorophyll a concentration
values. The second difficulty concerns the determinism of appearance
of the phytoplankton and zooplankton taxa used in the model: up to now
we are only able to force these appearances. Thus, even in quite simp
le ecosystems, using deterministic modelling as a predictive tool requ
ires a full understanding of the exact biological succession and inter
action processes.