Available ring current models for the calculation of proton shifts are
evaluated on the;basis of cyclophanes, which provide many protons abo
ve the aromatic plane in well-defined conformations. The latter were s
imulated with the help of MM2 and CHARMm force fields. Agreement betwe
en calculated and observed anisotropy effects approaching Delta delta(
av) = 0.17 ppm average deviation is found for 39 signals ranging over
6.6 ppm with the Johnson-Bovey model and the parameterization of doubl
e loop geometries p=0.64 Angstrom and r=1.39 Angstrom. The calculation
s include cyclophanes with protons in extremely close contact with the
it-surface, as reported recently by Pascal et al. and by Vogtle et al
. The calculations clarify some reported discrepancies but demonstrate
, in one and two cases, the presence of severe additional van der Waal
s (vdW) compression shifts which amount to as much as 1.6 ppm. The con
sequences of the extreme sensitivity of those proton locations near th
e shielding cone edges are discussed, in particular with respect to ap
plication to supramolecular structures or to biopolymers.