Rp. Sloan et al., TEMPORAL STABILITY OF HEART PERIOD VARIABILITY DURING A RESTING BASE-LINE AND IN RESPONSE TO PSYCHOLOGICAL CHALLENGE, Psychophysiology, 32(2), 1995, pp. 191-196
Central to the psychophysiologic reactivity hypothesis of the etiology
of coronary artery disease is the assumption that reactivity is an in
dividual characteristic that is stable over time. Although heart rate
(HR) and blood pressure reactivity appear to meet this criterion, temp
oral stability of cardiac autonomic control as measured by analysis of
heart period variability (HPV) has not been assessed. In this study,
we tested the stability of HPV, measured in both the time and frequenc
y domain, during a quiet, resting baseline and in response to 5-min me
ntal arithmetic and reaction time tasks, in 20 normal subjects measure
d in three testing sessions during a 9-month period. Stability, assess
ed by the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), was excellent for
resting baseline measures of HR and HPV, with ICCs of 0.68-0.86. Howev
er, HR and HPV reactivity to either arithmetic or reaction time tasks
generally was less stable, with ICCs of 0.17-0.73, in contrast to resu
lts of previous studies demonstrating longterm stability of HR respons
es to psychological challenge. Stability of aggregated reactivity scor
es was only slightly improved. Whether for individual tasks or aggrega
ted measures, reactivity of total and low-frequency measures of HPV wa
s moderately stable but stability of high-frequency HPV reactivity was
poor.