R. Klein et Om. Knio, ASYMPTOTIC VORTICITY STRUCTURE AND NUMERICAL-SIMULATION OF SLENDER VORTEX FILAMENTS, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 284, 1995, pp. 275-321
A new asymptotic analysis of slender vortices in three dimensions, bas
ed solely on the vorticity transport equation and the non-local vortic
ity-velocity relation gives new insight into the structure of slender
vortex filaments. The approach is quite different from earlier analyse
s using matched asymptotic solutions for the velocity field and it yie
lds additional information. This insight is used to derive three diffe
rent modifications of the thin-tube version of a numerical vortex elem
ent method. Our modifications remove an O(1) error from the node veloc
ities of the standard thin-tube model and allow us to properly account
for any prescribed physical vortex core structure independent of the
numerical vorticity smoothing function. We demonstrate the performance
of the improved models by comparison with asymptotic solutions for sl
ender vortex rings and for perturbed slender vortex filaments in the K
lein-Majda regime, in which the filament geometry is characterized by
small-amplitude-short-wavelength displacements from a straight line. T
hese comparisons represent a stringent mutual test for both the propos
ed modified thin-tube schemes and for the Klein-Majda theory. Importan
tly, we find a convincing agreement of numerical and asymptotic predic
tions for values of the Klein-Majda expansion parameter epsilon as lar
ge as 1/2. Thus, our results support their findings in earlier publica
tions for realistic physical vortex core sizes.