D. Nugent, ARTISANAL COOPERATION, FORMS OF LABOR, AND THE GLOBAL ECONOMY - CHACHAPOYAS, 1930S TO THE 1990S, Journal of historical sociology, 8(1), 1995, pp. 36-58
Since the 1960s students of agrarian society have interpreted the exis
tence of putatively ''capitalist'' economic practices and relations (e
.g., commoditization, wage labor, semi-proletarianization, etc.) in th
e rural Third World as evidence of the capitalist nature of the econom
ies concerned. The present paper challenges this interpretation. Based
on an analysis of artisanal production in the northern Peruvian Andes
, the paper shows that purportedly ''capitalist'' economic practices m
ay be fully commensurable with ''non-capitalist'' relations (e.g., for
ms of cooperation in the production process, kin ties, etc.), and may
even act as an obstacle to capital accumulation. ''Non-capitalist'' fo
rms of organizing the production process and of remunerating labor, on
the other hand, may be essential to the accumulation process.