E. Sobel et al., LACK OF ASSOCIATION OF APOLIPOPROTEIN-E ALLELE EPSILON-4 WITH LATE-ONSET ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE AMONG FINNISH CENTENARIANS, Neurology, 45(5), 1995, pp. 903-907
No association between Alzheimer's disease (AD) and apolipoprotein E t
ype epsilon 4 (ApoE epsilon 4) phenotype was found among centenarians
in Finland (N = 179). The data are based on ascertainment of all cente
narians in Finland in 1991. All examinations were conducted during 199
1. The diagnoses of dementia and AD were based on clinical grounds, co
nforming to DSM-III-R and NINCDS-ADRDA criteria, The percentage of Apo
E epsilon 4 alleles among the centenarians was 8.7% (31 of 358 alleles
). This is significantly lower than percentages found in younger Finni
sh populations, Thirty (16.8%) of the 179 centenarians were epsilon 4
allele carriers, One hundred fifty-one (84.4%) of the centenarians wer
e women. Twenty-eight (18.5%) of the women had at least one epsilon 4
allele, as did two (7.1%) of the men. The prevalence of clinically dia
gnosed AD was 26.8%; 44% of the subjects were cognitively normal, 23%
had signs of cognitive decline or at most mild dementia (with no diffe
rential diagnosis), and 6% had a dementia clinically diagnosed as bein
g due to some cause other than AD. For AD cases versus cognitively nor
mal subjects, the odds ratio associated with being a carrier of the ep
silon 4 allele was 1.34 (p = 0.64; 95% CI = [0.5, 3.3]). Among women,
the odds ratio was 0.99 (p = 1.0; 95% CI = [0.4, 2.6]). There were few
er, but not significantly so, epsilon 4 carriers among subjects with c
ognitive decline or at most mild dementia (12.2%) than there were amon
g the cognitively normal subjects (16.5%). Ten (10.4%) of the 96 allel
es belonging to AD cases were epsilon 4, and 8.9% (14/158) of the alle
les belonging to the cognitively normal subjects were epsilon 4. This
difference is highly nonsignificant. There was only one individual who
was homozygous for the epsilon 4 allele. She was cognitively normal.
Among the 28 men in the study there were only two carriers of the epsi
lon 4 allele; consequently, analyses for men have little power. These
results clearly show that the epsilon 4 allele does not necessarily le
ad to AD even near the (current) upper age-limit of life. When combine
d with previous findings, these results suggest that the association o
f the ApoE epsilon 4 allele with AD may be age-dependent and that the
ApoE epsilon 4 allele might accelerate the AD dementing process rather
than be a direct etiologic agent or a predisposing genetic factor.