Ms. Wogalter et al., COMPLIANCE TO OWNERS MANUAL WARNINGS - INFLUENCE OF FAMILIARITY AND THE PLACEMENT OF A SUPPLEMENTAL DIRECTIVE, Ergonomics, 38(6), 1995, pp. 1081-1091
This research examined several methods of directing people to warnings
in an owner's manual in order to increase compliance behaviour during
the installation of a computer disk drive. Seven conditions were exam
ined. In the control condition, the disk drive was accompanied by a ba
sic manual that contained equipment-safety warnings on pages 6 and 7.
In another condition, the manual was identical except that the warning
s were also reprinted redundantly on page 2 of the manual (which was b
lank in the basic manual). The remaining five conditions were identica
l to the redundant-warning condition, except that they also included a
supplemental directive that was placed at various locations (on the s
hipping box, cover page of the manual, accompanying leaflet, disk driv
e cable, and front of the drive). The directive stated 'Please Read Pa
ge 2 of the Owner's Manual Before Connecting the Equipment'. The resul
ts show a trend of greater compliance with the redundant-warning (only
) manual compared to the basic manual, but the difference was not stat
istically significant. When the supplemental directive was located mos
t proximally to the equipment and required physical interaction with t
he warning during the task (front-of-drive condition), compliance was
significantly greater than the basic and redundant-warning (only) manu
al conditions. The results also show that, in general, users with less
experience connecting electronic equipment complied more frequently w
ith the warnings than users with greater experience. Additional result
s indicate that less experienced users were not further influenced by
the presence and location of the supplemental directive, but highly ex
perienced users complied more often when the supplemental directive wa
s placed in the more proximal locations. The results are discussed in
relation to script theory and to previous research on familiarity. The
present study suggests that well-placed safety information can be use
ful in alerting users with varying levels of experience.