A recently proposed method for calibrating lumped rainfall-runoff mode
ls, called FDTF-ERUHDIT, is analysed and evaluated on synthetic data.
Based on the Unit Hydrograph concept this method performs a simultaneo
us identification of the excess rainfall se;ies and the transfer funct
ion or unit hydrograph through an alternating iterative procedure with
out presuming any runoff production model or applying any arbitrary ba
seflow removal. A general evaluation framework was built to allow for
generation of realistic data both error-free and contaminated with con
trolled errors. The problems of the method's convergence and sensitivi
ty to errors in the data and the model structure assumed are tackled.
A rather exhaustive series of tests involve also evaluations of the ef
fects of a priori choices of optimisation algorithms and their paramet
ers, as well as assessments of sampling effects. Combinations of these
factors are also tested. Finally, useful guidelines for practical use
of the new identification approach are derived.