Predicting the size of low-probability, high-consequence natural disas
ters, industrial accidents, and pollutant releases is often difficult
due to limitations in the availability of data on rare events and futu
re circumstances. When incident data are available, they may be diffic
ult to fit with a lognormal distribution. Two Bayesian probability dis
tributions for inferring future incident-size probabilities from limit
ed, indirect, and subjective information are proposed in this paper. T
he distributions are derived from Pareto distributions that are shown
to fit data on different incident types and are justified theoreticall
y. The derived distributions incorporate both inherent variability and
uncertainty due to information limitations. Results were analyzed to
determine the amount of data needed to predict incident-size probabili
ties in various situations. Information requirements for incident-size
prediction using the methods were low, particularly when the populati
on distribution had a thick tail. Use of the distributions to predict
accumulated oil-spill consequences was demonstrated.