Am. Shanberg et al., DEPTH OF PENETRATION OF THE NEODYMIUM-YTTRIUM-ALUMINUM-GARNET LASER IN THE HUMAN PROSTATE AND CLINICAL-RESULTS OF HIGH-DOSE LASER ENERGY IN50 PATIENTS, World journal of urology, 13(2), 1995, pp. 78-82
We evaluated the treatment of the human prostate with the Nd:YAG laser
using a Cytocare Prolase II fiber. We utilized this first in 12 patie
nts prior to radical prostatectomy and then appropriately serially sec
tioned the prostate to measure the depth of penetration. The studies c
learly revealed that 60 W of power and 60 s of pulse duration gave the
most consistent depth of penetration in the human prostate model. Thi
s depth of penetration averaged 2 cm in the glands that were removed.
At the same time there was absolutely no evidence of damage to the neu
rovascular bundle or to the capsule of the prostate using the above-me
ntioned dosimetry regime. This study was then transferred to our initi
al experience in treating 50 patients with benign prostatic hypertroph
y and obstructive voiding symptoms. The first 25 patients were also tr
eated with so-called spot radiation of the prostate, whereas the secon
d 25 patients were treated by total photoirradiation of all visible en
doscopic tissue. The results reveal that both groups of patients had a
fairly highly satisfactory result as measured objectively with Americ
an Urological Association (AUA) symptom scores and uroflow studies. In
the latter group (photoirradiation of all visible endoscopic tissue)
a significantly higher dose of laser energy was utilized and a smaller
failure rate was noted on a long-term basis in patients who subsequen
tly came to transurethral resection of the prostate (TURF) because of
failure of the laser procedure. At the same time that the patients wer
e treated, all 50 patients underwent multiple random needle biopsies o
f the peripheral zone of the prostate, and at no time was there any ev
idence of a laser effect in the capsule of the human prostate from a d
osimetry of 60 W and 60 s of pulse duration and total photoirradiation
of the entire prostate. Very large doses of energy were used, ranging
up to 110,000 J per case. It is our impression that the 60-W/60-s pro
tocol will consistently yield the best results in terms of success of
laser prostatectomy as measured objectively with uroflow and AUA sympt
om score as well as providing total safety in term of the absence of d
amage to the capsule of the prostate despite photoirradiation of all v
isible viable tissue at high total doses of energy.