Al. Burke et al., MODEL DISCRIMINATION VIA DESIGNED EXPERIMENTS - DISCRIMINATION BETWEEN THE TERMINAL AND PENULTIMATE MODELS BASED ON RATE DATA, Chemical Engineering Science, 50(10), 1995, pp. 1619-1634
Simulations have been used to study the application of model discrimin
ation methods to the problem of discriminating between the terminal an
d penultimate copolymerization models on the basis of composition and
rate data. Both models are reviewed and the three model discrimination
methods chosen for study are explained. Composition data have been us
ed in conjunction with rate data due to the high correlation between e
stimated parameters based solely on rate data. This correlation has be
en discussed. The simulation programs are then explained including the
generation of simulated data. Data are presented to show that the sim
ulation programs can duplicate the experimental observations of other
researchers. The results show that both the modified Buzzi-Ferraris me
thod and the exact entropy method are able to correctly discriminate b
etween the models in greater than 95% of the simulations. Differences
between the three model discrimination methods are discussed along wit
h differences between the three copolymer measurements that have been
studied.