Protandry, the early emergence of males into a seasonally breeding pop
ulation, has been described mathematically as a mating strategy result
ing from sexual selection on both sexes; A key implicit assumption in
protandry models is that all matings contribute equally to a male's re
productive success. We build a simulation model of protandry based on
field censuses and investigate the consequences of size-specific tempo
ral variation in female fecundity for the optimal timing of protandry
in the western treehole mosquito, Aedes sierrensis. We show that theor
etical predictions of protandry are robust when differential female fe
cundity is incorporated into a model of protandry in A. sierrensis. In
addition, we utilize field data and laboratory experiments to elucida
te the selective forces acting on both sexes of this mosquito. Under c
onditions of reduced per capita resources, males minimized development
time by pupating at lower mass; females maximized mass by delaying pu
pation. These gender-specific, homeostatic adjustments to food and den
sity, which result in density-dependent protandry, indicate that prota
ndry is the result of selection on independent fitness criteria in eac
h sex.