Pf. Arthur et al., POPULATION ANALYSIS OF A PUREBRED HEREFORD AND A MULTIBREED SYNTHETICBEEF-CATTLE HERD, Genetics selection evolution, 27(2), 1995, pp. 135-148
Lifetime records of females born from 1966 to 1975 were used to estima
te and compare population parameters of a purebred Hereford (HE) and a
multibreed synthetic (SY1) beef cattle herd raised under a stringent
culling policy whereby heifers and cows failing to wean a calf each ye
ar were culled. Population size averaged 118 cows, 39 heifers and 155
cows, 56 heifers a year for HE and SY1, respectively. The SY1 was a mu
ltibreed composite breed group with an average breed composition of 33
% Charolais, 33% Angus, and 20% Galloway, and the remainder from other
beef breeds. The 2 herds were raised under the same management. Nine
life table statistics were studied: age-specific survivorship, age-spe
cific survival rate, mortality rates (Qx), expected herd life, age-spe
cific birth rate, reproductive value, net reproductive rate (Ro); inst
antaneous rate of population increase (r) and generation interval (T).
Differences were obtained between the herds for the age-specific life
table statistics, with SY1 having higher values (except for lower Qa
values) than HE. SY1 had higher means than HE for Ro (1.57 +/- 0.11 ve
rsus 1.21 +/- 0.15; p < 0.07) and r (0.09 +/- 0.01 versus 0.03 +/- 0.0
2; p < 0.04), indicating a faster rate of population growth in SY1. Th
e value of T for SY1 was higher (p < 0.01) than that for HE (5.09 +/-
0.11 versus 4.25 +/- 0.19 years). The results indicate that the same m
anagement and culling policy may result in different life. table stati
stics, which in this study was possibly due to the influence of hetero
sis for calf survival in the multibreed composite SY1 herd. Over time
the stringent culling policy had the effect of reducing Ro, r and T va
lues to the point where herd size in the HE herd could not be maintain
ed (Ro < 1 in the 1972 and later cohorts).