The implications of constraints on unitary transformations of spin ope
rators with respect to the accessible regions of Liouville space are a
nalyzed. Specifically, the effects of spin-permutation symmetry on the
unitary propagators are investigated. The influence of S-2 and S-3 pr
opagator symmetry on two-dimensional bounds for F-z = Sigma(i=1)(N) 1(
iz) <-> G(z) = Sigma(j=1)(M) S-jz polarization transfer in IS and I2S
spin-1/2 systems is examined in detail. One result 2 is that the maxim
um achievable F-z <-> G(z) polarization transfer is not reduced by per
mutation symmetry among the spins. For I2S spin systems, S-3 symmetry
in the unitary propagator is shown to significantly reduce the accessi
ble region in the 2D F-z-S-z Liouville subspace compared to the case r
estricted by unitarity alone. That result is compared with transformat
ions under symmetric dipolar and scalar J coupling as well as shift an
d RF interactions. An important practical implication is that the refi
ned spin thermodynamic theory of Levitt, Suter, and Ernst (J. Chem. Ph
ys. 84, 4243, 1986) for cross polarization in solid-state NMR does not
predict experimental outcomes incompatible with constraints of unitar
ity and spin-permutation symmetry. (C) 1995 Academic Press, Inc.