D. Smith et O. Osterud, THE NATION-STATE, NATURALISM AND POLITICA L IDENTITY - PROPOSAL FOR ASCHOLARLY AGENDA, Internasjonal politikk, 54(4), 1996, pp. 435
The issues of nationalism, the European order of nation-states and the
role of group identity are high on both the political and the scholar
ly agenda of our time. Although there is a rich scholarly literature o
n these topics, there remain important areas of doubt and obscurity. T
his article sets out to explore both political realities and to assess
the current state of theoretical and empirical research. The enquiry
is structured by the three inter-related topics presented in the title
. It looks in turn at the viability of the nation-state in the current
period, the relationship of nationalism and modernity, and the ever-s
hifting categories and salience of group identities. In contradiction
with some currently accepted theorising, the article finds grounds for
concluding that the days of the nation-state are not necessarily comi
ng to an end. While accepting much of the basis of mainstream theory o
n nationalism, the article also suggests that the relationship between
nationalism and modernity may be overestimated by some of the leading
figures. And in the literature on identity, the article concludes tha
t it has become commonplace to acknowledge the multiple levels and cat
egories of identity - it is the shift from one to another that especia
lly needs further attention. In relation to each of the three parallel
themes, the article identifies frameworks and strategies for research
along the most theoretically fruitful and politically relevant lines
of enquiry.