EVALUATING THE PERFORMANCE OF VALUE VERSUS GLAMOUR STOCKS - THE IMPACT OF SELECTION BIAS

We examine whether sample selection bias explains the difference in re turns between 'value' stocks (high book-to-market ratios) and 'glamour ' stocks (low book-to-market ratios). Selection bias on Compustat is n ot a severe problem: for CRSP primary domestic firms, the proportion m issing from Compustat is not large and the average return is not very different from the Compustat sample. Mechanical problems with matching Cusip identifiers account for much of the discrepancy between CRSP an d Compustat. The superior performance of value stocks is confirmed for the top quintile of NYSE-Amex stocks, using a sample free from select ion bias.