Dc. Tarng et al., IRON-METABOLISM INDEXES FOR EARLY PREDICTION OF THE RESPONSE AND RESISTANCE TO ERYTHROPOIETIN THERAPY IN MAINTENANCE HEMODIALYSIS-PATIENTS, American journal of nephrology, 15(3), 1995, pp. 230-237
A prospective study with 65 maintenance hemodialysis (MHD) patients on
recombinant human erythropoietin (rHuEPO) therapy was conducted to as
sess the effect of iron balance on responsiveness. An attempt to defin
e the predictors of erythropoietin (EPO) response and identify the spe
cific causes of EPO resistance was undertaken in the present study. Th
e treatment protocol consisted of two stages, the first was rHuEPO the
rapy for 6 months and the second was iron supplementation plus rHuEPO
therapy in patients without response to EPO for the next 6 months. Acc
ording to the hemoglobin (Hb) changes (increment exceeded 30% of basel
ine or did not exceed 15% of baseline for 3 consecutive months) and wh
ether or not there was an achievement of target Hb level (> 10.5 g/dl)
, all patients (n = 65) were divided into EPO-responsive (n = 20) and
EPO-resistant (n = 45) groups. The EPO-resistant patients were then fu
rther stratified into iron-responsive (n = 29) and iron-irresponsive (
n = 16) groups. Iron metabolism and red cell indices were analyzed pri
or to and following rHuEPO therapy and iron supplementation. We found
the following: (1) only serum ferritin (SF) was a reliable discriminat
or between the EPO-responsive (SF >300 mu g/l) and EPO-resistant (SF <
300 mu g/l) groups; (2) similarly, transferrin saturation (TFS) 25% wa
s quoted as the best cut-off value between the iron-responsive (TFS <2
5%) and iron-irresponsive (TFS >25%) groups; (3) EPO-resistant patient
s with TFS <25% regained proper EPO response (Hb before and 6 months a
fter therapy: 7.8 +/- 0.9 vs. 10.6 +/- 0.8 g/dl, p < 0.01) and the mea
n TFS increased significantly (initial TFS and peak level after therap
y: 18.9 +/- 4.7 vs. 34.5 +/- 10.8%, p < 0.01) following iron therapy;
(4) the cumulative incidence of TFS <25% elevated to 44.5% 6 months fo
llowing initial rHuEPO therapy, and (5) there was a strong inverse rel
ationship between initial TFS and the changes of Hb following iron the
rapy in EPO-resistant patients (r = -0.75, p < 0.0001). By means of ea
rly detection and correction of functional iron deficiency, the goal o
f increment of therapeutic efficacy and prevention from unnecessarily
high doses of rHuEPO can be achieved. In summary, SF >300 mu g/l equat
es adequate or increased body iron stores and seems to exclude iron de
ficiency in MI-ID patients. On the contrary, SF less than or equal to
300 mu g/l appears to be an insufficient diagnostic threshold for iron
deficiency. Once resistance occurs during the rHuEPO therapy, in our
opinion only patients with TFS <25% need iron supplementation. However
, in patients with TFS >25% and resistance to EPO, further investigati
ons are necessary before increasing the dose of rHuEPO to explore othe
r possible conditions, such as aluminum overload, severe hyperparathyr
oidism, occult blood loss or hemolysis, and episodes of infection or i
nflammatory processes.