G. Head et al., DIRECT AND INDIRECT SELECTION ON BEHAVIORAL-RESPONSE TO PERMETHRIN INLARVAL DIAMONDBACK MOTHS (LEPIDOPTERA, PLUTELLIDAE), Journal of economic entomology, 88(3), 1995, pp. 461-469
Both physiological tolerance to the pyrethroid permethrin and behavior
al response to permethrin have been shown to have some genetic basis i
n the diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella (L.). Hence, selection bas
ed on these characters should be possible. We investigated the direct
and indirect effects of selection on physiological tolerance and behav
ioral responsiveness, and how these effects vary across populations. W
orking with four populations for which genetic information was availab
le, we created three groups within each population by selecting for be
havioral responsiveness and unresponsiveness, and by separately select
ing for physiological tolerance. Tile effects of selection were evalua
ted by assaying the offspring of these groups. In all four populations
, the dominant effects of selection were on physiological tolerance. P
hysiological tolerance was higher in those groups selected directly ba
sed on tolerance, and those selected for behavioral unresponsiveness,
than in the groups selected for behavioral responsiveness. In addition
, tolerance was higher in the groups selected for tolerance and behavi
oral unresponsiveness than in the parental generation in all but one p
opulation. We observed no clear patterns with respect to the behaviora
l character. Direct selection for responsiveness was successful in onl
y one population. Selection based on tolerance did not indirectly prod
uce shifts. in behavior. At least two elements of behavior, however we
re affected by selection: first, general responsiveness as shown by be
havioral variation independent of permethrin; second, an increased ten
dency to avoid permethrin especially at high toxin concentrations. The
se effects varied among the populations apparently as a result of vari
ation in genetic parameters.