The advent of mammographic breast screening has increased the detectio
n of ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), which now accounts for 15-20% of
all breast cancer. While symptomatic DCIS has been treated satisfacto
rily by mastectomy, this may be an overtreatment of smaller screen-det
ected lesions. Although local excision, with or without radiotherapy,
is associated with a significant risk of local recurrence of DCIS or i
nvasive cancer, salvage surgery is usually successful. The long-term b
reast-specific mortality rate of treatment by mastectomy and local exc
ision are similar. Whereas mastectomy is still appropriate for women w
ith lesions > 30 mm in diameter or centrally placed and for those wome
n who demand the best possible disease-free survival, local surgery sh
ould otherwise be considered.