P. Vanderschot et al., A REVIEW ON 161 SUBTROCHANTERIC FRACTURES - RISK-FACTORS INFLUENCING OUTCOME - AGE, FRACTURE PATTERN AND FRACTURE LEVEL, Der Unfallchirurg, 98(5), 1995, pp. 265-271
The results obtained in 161 subtrochanteric fractures of the femur fol
lowing treatment with a 95 degrees condylar blade plate or a dynamic c
ondylar screw or a gamma nail were retrospectively analyzed. A 95 degr
ees angular blade plate was used in 107 cases, a dynamic condylar scre
w in 25, and a gamma nail in 29. There were 114 patients who were admi
tted after a simple fall and 47 who had sustained a high-energy trauma
. In the type of trauma, associated lesions, ISS, pre-existing disease
s and finally age we found statistically significant difference (P < 0
.001) between patients admitted after a simple fall and patients admit
ted after a high-energy trauma. The mean operating times for the 95 de
grees angled blade plate, the dynamic condylar screw and the gamma nai
l were 86, 85 and 74 min, respectively. Of the 161 patients, 18 requir
ed a revision operation. Of these 18 patients, 8 were initially treate
d using a 95 degrees condylar blade plate, 2 with a dynamic condylar s
crew and finally 8 with insertion of a gamma nail; 5 of these patients
were less than 70 years old, while the other 13 were older than 70 ye
ars (P = 0.025; Fisher's exact test P = 0.042). The post-injury roentg
enogram showed a fracture at the level of the lesser trochanter in 11
of the patients older than 50 years (P = 0.017; Fisher exact P = 0.053
). Among the 18 patients who underwent revision operations, the post-i
njury roentgenograms showed 6 type IIIA fractures and 5 type V fractur
es. There was a statistically significant difference in fracture type
between age groups above and below 50 years (P = 0.095; Fisher exact P
= 0.043).