G. Firebaugh et Fd. Beck, DOES ECONOMIC-GROWTH BENEFIT THE MASSES - GROWTH, DEPENDENCE, AND WELFARE IN THE THIRD-WORLD, American sociological review, 59(5), 1994, pp. 631-653
Despite recent economic gains in much of the Third World, sociologists
have paid little attention to the possible national benefits of econo
mic growth. Instead, they have focused on the possible harm caused by
the Third World's dependence on foreign investment and trade. Our anal
ysis questions that focus. Based on data for 62 less-developed countri
es spanning two decades, we find that the effects of dependence largel
y vanish when (1) the effects of economic growth are carefully specifi
ed, and (2) the ''semi-difference'' models currently in vogue in cross
-national research are replaced by more appropriate difference or diff
erence-of-logs (growth-rare) models. In light of the common claim that
economic growth in the Third World benefits only the rich, we employ
measures of national welfare that the rich cannot readily monopolize.
The effects of economic growth on national welfare are large and robus
t, whereas the effects of dependence are hard to find. These findings
contradict earlier studies, which had concluded that the effects of de
pendence dwarf the effects of economic growth.