This paper present the results of a trade study to predict aeroheating
and thermal protection system (TPS) requirements for manned entry veh
icles returning to Earth from the moon. The objectives of tile study w
ere to assess the effects of vehicle size and lunar return strategies
on both the aerothermodynamic environment and the TPS design. The stud
y guidelines were based on an Apollo Command Module (CM) configuration
for scales of 1.0, 1.5, and 2.5. Lunar return strategies included dir
ect entry and aerocapture followed by low Earth orbit entry. Convectiv
e heating was obtained by the boundary-layer integral matrix procedure
code, and radiative heating was computed with the QRAD program. The A
ESOP-STAB code was used for TPS analysis for ablating materials, and t
he AESOP-THERM code was used for nonablating materials. Principal resu
lts indicated that there was an optimum size for minimum heating with
the Apollo CM-shaped vehicles, although heating rates were not a stron
g function of vehicle size. Direct entry had significantly higher heat
ing rates than aerocapture; however, aerocapture resulted in higher he
at loads and TPS weight. The TPS weight factor (ratio of TPS weight to
total vehicle weight) was 6-8% for all lunar return strategies using
an Avco ablator on the forebody and FRCI-12/LI-900 on the aftbody, wit
h the TPS weight being about 50% less than that of the original Apollo
CM vehicle.