BONE-MINERAL DENSITY IN RELATION TO MEDICAL AND LIFE-STYLE RISK-FACTORS FOR OSTEOPOROSIS IN PREMENOPAUSAL, MENOPAUSAL AND POSTMENOPAUSAL WOMEN IN GENERAL-PRACTICE
A. Mcknight et al., BONE-MINERAL DENSITY IN RELATION TO MEDICAL AND LIFE-STYLE RISK-FACTORS FOR OSTEOPOROSIS IN PREMENOPAUSAL, MENOPAUSAL AND POSTMENOPAUSAL WOMEN IN GENERAL-PRACTICE, British journal of general practice, 45(395), 1995, pp. 317-320
Background. Interest in the prevention of osteoporosis is increasing a
nd thus there is a need for an acceptable osteoporosis prevention prog
ramme in general practice. Aim. A study was undertaken to identify a c
ohort of middle-aged women attending a general practice who would be e
ligible for a longitudinal study looking at bone mineral density, oste
oporosis and the effectiveness of hormone replacement therapy. This st
udy aimed to describe the relationship between medical and lifestyle r
isk factors for osteoporosis and the initial bone density measurements
in this group of women. Method. A health visitor administered a quest
ionnaire to women aged between 48 and 52 years registered with a Belfa
st general practice. The main outcome measures were menopausal status,
presence of medical and lifestyle risk factors and bone mineral densi
ty measurements. Results. A total of 358 women out of 472 (76%) took p
art in the study which was conducted in 1991 and 1992. A highly signif
icant difference was found between the mean bone mineral density of pr
emenopausal, menopausal and postmenopausal women within the narrow stu
dy age range, postmenopausal women having the lowest bone mineral dens
ity. A significant relationship was found between body mass index and
bone mineral density, a greater bone mineral density being found among
women with a higher body mass index. Risk factors such as smoking and
sedentary lifestyle were common (reported by approximately one third
of respondents) but a poor relationship was found between these two an
d all the other risk factors and bone mineral density in this age grou
p. Conclusion. Risk of osteoporosis cannot be identified by the presen
ce of risk factors in women aged between 48 and 52 years. In terms of
a current prevention strategy for general practice it would be better
to take a population-based approach except for those women known to be
at high risk of osteoporosis: women with early menopause or those who
have had an oophorectomy.