Fc. Verhulst et Tm. Achenbach, EMPIRICALLY BASED ASSESSMENT AND TAXONOMY OF PSYCHOPATHOLOGY - CROSS-CULTURAL APPLICATIONS - A REVIEW, European child & adolescent psychiatry, 4(2), 1995, pp. 61-76
This paper provides an overview of empirically based assessment and ta
xonomy, as illustrated by cross-cultural research on psychopathology.
The empirically based approach uses standardized assessment procedures
to score behavioral and emotional problems from which syndromes are d
erived by multivariate analyses. Items and syndromes are scored quanti
tatively to reflect the degree to which individuals manifest them, as
reported by particular informants. Although the approach to assessing
problems and to constructing taxonomic groupings differs from the ICD/
DSM approach, there are no inherent contradictions between either thei
r models for disorders nor the criterial features used to define disor
ders. Cross-cultural comparisons have yielded relatively small differe
nces in problem rates and syndrome structure, plus considerable simila
rity in associations of problems with sex and SES, as well as similar
correlations between reports by different types of informants. Researc
h on variations in problems in relation to culture, sex, age, SES, and
type of informant can contribute to improving both the ICD/DSM and em
pirically based approaches and to a more effective synthesis between t
hem.