Standard benefit-incidence analysis does not distinguish policy impact
s on persistent poverty from transient poverty. We offer an alternativ
e approach, based on actual and simulated joint distributions of consu
mption over time, which allows us to distinguish the extent of 'protec
tion' against poverty from 'promotion' out of poverty. The approach is
illustrated by an analysis of the distributional impact of changes in
cash benefits introduced to compensate for other policy reforms in Hu
ngary. Cash benefits protected many from poverty, but promoted few out
of poverty. The safety net's impact on poverty was largely due to hig
her average outlays, rather than improved targeting.