Signature files have been studied extensively as an access method for
textual databases. Many approaches have been proposed for searching si
gnatures files efficiently. However, different methods make different
assumptions and use different performance measures, making it difficul
t to compare their performance. In this paper, we study three basic me
thods proposed in the literature, namely, the indexed descriptor file,
the two-level superimposed coding scheme, and the partitioned signatu
re file approach. The contribution of this paper is two-fold. First, w
e present a uniform analytical performance model so that the methods c
an be compared fairly and consistently. The analysis shows that the tw
o-level superimposed coding scheme, if stored in a transposed file, ha
s the best performance. Second, we extend the two-level superimposed c
oding method into a multilevel superimposed coding method, we obtain t
he optimal number of levels for the multilevel method and show that fo
r databases with reasonable size the optimal value is much larger than
2, which is assumed in the two-level method. The accuracy of the anal
ytical formula is demonstrated by simulation.