Dm. Christodoulou et al., PHASE-TRANSITION THEORY OF INSTABILITIES .1. 2ND-HARMONIC INSTABILITYAND BIFURCATION POINTS, The Astrophysical journal, 446(2), 1995, pp. 472-484
We use a free-energy minimization approach to describe in simple and c
lear physical terms the secular and dynamical instabilities as well as
the bifurcations along well-known sequences of rotating, self-gravita
ting fluid and stellar systems such as the Maclaurin spheroids, the Ja
cobi, Dedekind, and Riemann ellipsoids, and the fluid/stellar disks. O
ur approach stems from the Ginzburg-Landau theory of phase transitions
. In this paper, we focus on the Maclaurin sequence of oblate spheroid
al equilibria and on the effects of nonaxisymmetric, second-harmonic d
isturbances. The free-energy approach has been pioneered in astrophysi
cs by Bertin and Radicati (1976) who showed that the secular instabili
ty beyond the Maclaurin-Jacobi bifurcation can be interpreted as a sec
ond-order phase transition. We show that second-order phase transition
s appear on the Maclaurin sequence also at the points of dynamical ins
tability (bifurcation of the x = +1 self-adjoint Riemann sequence) and
of bifurcation of the Dedekind sequence. The distinguishing character
istic of each second-order phase transition is the conservation/noncon
servation of an integral of motion (a ''conserved/nonconserved current
'') which, in effect, determines uniquely whether the transition appea
rs or not. The secular instability beyond the Jacobi bifurcation appea
rs only if circulation is not conserved. The secular instability at th
e Dedekind bifurcation appears only if angular momentum is not conserv
ed. We show by an explicit calculation that, in the presence of dissip
ation agents that violate one or the other conservation law, the globa
l minimum of the free-energy function beyond the onset of secular inst
ability belongs to the Jacobi and to the Dedekind sequence, respective
ly. In the case of a ''perfect'' fluid which conserves both circulatio
n and angular momentum, the ''secular'' phase transitions are no longe
r realized and the Jacobi/Dedekind bifurcation point becomes irrelevan
t. The Maclaurin spheroid remains at the global minimum of the free-en
ergy function up to the bifurcation point of the x = +1 Riemann sequen
ce. The x = +1 equilibria have lower free energy than the correspondin
g Maclaurin spheroids for the same values of angular momentum and circ
ulation. Thus, a ''dynamical'' second-order phase transition is allowe
d to take place beyond this bifurcation point. This phase transition b
rings the spheroid, now sitting at a saddle point of the free-energy f
unction, to the new global minimum on the x = +1 Riemann sequence. Cir
culation is not conserved in stellar systems because the stress-tenser
gradient terms that appear in the Jeans equations of motion include '
'viscosity-like'' off-diagonal terms of the same order of magnitude as
the conventional ''pressure'' gradient terms. For this reason, global
ly unstable axisymmetric stellar systems evolve toward the ''stellar''
Jacobi sequence on dynamical timescales. This explains why the Jacobi
bifurcation is a point of dynamical instability in stellar systems bu
t only a point of secular instability in viscous fluids. The second-or
der phase transitions on the Maclaurin sequence are discussed in relat
ion to the dynamical instability of stellar systems, the lambda-transi
tion of liquid He-4, the second-order phase transition in superconduct
ivity, and the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking.