Dp. Saccuzzo et Ne. Johnson, TRADITIONAL PSYCHOMETRIC TESTS AND PROPORTIONATE REPRESENTATION - AN INTERVENTION AND PROGRAM-EVALUATION STUDY, Psychological assessment, 7(2), 1995, pp. 183-194
The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R) and Stan
dard Raven Progressive Matrices (SPM) Test were evaluated in the conte
xt of an intervention/program evaluation study and in terms of a propo
rtionate representation model of test bias. A total of 26,300 boys and
girls from 8 different ethnic backgrounds were evaluated over a 9-yea
r period. An intervention based on monitoring of and feedback to refer
ral sources proved effective in improving proportionate representation
in the referral process. Moreover, the WISC-R and SPM showed approxim
ately equal predictive validity and no evidence of differential validi
ty. Significant differences were found as a function of ethnic backgro
und between those referred and those certified as gifted, as well as b
etween those referred and those who scored in the 98th percentile on e
ither test. Implications for traditional tests are discussed.