A visual sentence-picture matching task was used to clarify the nature
of the comprehension deficit in Alzheimer's Disease (AD). Test senten
ces varied according to how crucial the processing of syntax was in co
mputing a correct interpretation. Half the sentences could be understo
od through the comprehension of semantic cues alone; the other half re
quired the processing of syntactic cues. In the first experiment, sent
ences were removed from view before the test pictures were presented;
in the second, sentences and pictures were presented together to decre
ase demands on working memory. Two factors determined the accuracy of
sentence comprehension: whether a syntactic analysis was needed and wh
ether additional working-memory resources were needed for temporary st
orage. When storage demands were minimized, patients were able to use
semantic cues to guide comprehension. When semantic cues were unavaila
ble, comprehension was impaired, regardless of whether or not there we
re additional storage requirements, providing evidence for a genuine s
yntactic deficit that is not due to coexisting semantic impairment or
working-memory dysfunction.