Lp. Olson et Tc. Bruice, ELECTRON-TUNNELING AND AB-INITIO CALCULATIONS RELATED TO THE ONE-ELECTRON OXIDATION OF NAD(P)H BOUND TO CATALASE, Biochemistry, 34(22), 1995, pp. 7335-7347
Models for NAD(P)H 1e(-) oxidation in bovine catalase were studied usi
ng Hartree-Fock ab initio calculations, along with information taken f
rom the published X-ray structure of the enzyme. Geometries and energi
es of ground states and transition states were calculated at the 6-31G
() level for N-methyl-1,4-dihydropyridine and N-methyl-1,4-dihydronic
otinamide undergoing the pathway (i) 1e(-) oxidation to yield the radi
cal cation, (ii) general-base-catalyzed (hydroxide and/or imidazole) d
eprotonation of the radical cation to yield the neutral radical, and (
iii) 1e(-) oxidation of the neutral radical to the N-methylpyridinium
or N-methylnicotinamide cation. Barrier heights for deprotonation of t
he radical cation intermediates were calculated to be 7-11 kcal/mol. K
inetic isotope effects were calculated for general-base-catalyzed depr
otonation of the N-methyl-1,4-dihydropyridine radical cation and the 4
,4-dideuterio species and found to be k(H)/k(D2) = 5.38 (hydroxide) or
3.64 (imidazole), in qualitative agreement with published experimenta
l isotope effects for the analogous deprotonation of N-methyl-1,10-dih
ydroacridan or the N-methyl-1,10-dideuterioacridan radical cation. In
the calculated transition state for imidazole deprotonation of the N-m
ethyl-1,4-dihydronicotinamide radical cation, an unusual short contact
was calculated and interpreted as a hydrogen bond (2.35 Angstrom) bet
ween the amide oxygen and the hydrogen attached to C2 of imidazole. Si
milar hydrogen bonds were also observed and calculated at the 3-21G an
d 6-31G() levels between His234 of catalase and the amide oxygen of b
ound NAD(P)H and complexes of N,N'-dimethyl-1,4-dihydronicotinamide or
cis-N-methylformamide with N-methylimidazole. Comparison of these res
ults to the X-ray structure of bovine catalase allows for further inte
rpretation of the possible roles of the imidazole bases His234 and His
304 and the hydrogen-bonded contacts in the NAD(P)H binding site. Elec
tron tunneling pathways between NAD(P)H and the iron protoporphyrin IX
(PP-M) axial tyrosinate ligand Tyr357 in molecular dynamics and X-ray
crystal structures of bovine catalase were calculated using PATHWAYS
II (version 2.01). The pathways which were calculated included those i
nvolving the amino acid residue Tyr214, which is near the NAD(P)H bind
ing site. Coupling involving Tyr357 was not particularly efficient; ho
wever, strong coupling between Tyr214 and iron-protoporphyrin IX was o
bserved. These pathways may be important if electron transfer is stepw
ise; i.e., Tyr214 oxidized first, followed by NAD(P)H.