Sc. Singhi et al., FLUID RESTRICTION DOES NOT IMPROVE THE OUTCOME OF ACUTE MENINGITIS, The Pediatric infectious disease journal, 14(6), 1995, pp. 495-503
The objective of this prospective study was to examine the effect of f
luid restriction on body water and the outcome of children with acute
meningitis, Fifty consecutively hospitalized children with acute menin
gitis, divided into two groups (A, without hyponatremia; and B, with h
yponatremia), were randomly assigned to receive either normal maintena
nce (M) or restricted (R subgroup) (65 to 70% of M subgroup) fluids du
ring the first 48 hours, Total body water, extracellular water (ECW),
serum and urinary sodium and plasma and urinary osmolality were measur
ed at admission and after 48 hours, In both groups children receiving
restricted fluids showed a significant decrease in the mean total body
water and ECW whereas body water remained unchanged in those on maint
enance fluids, Children having art ECW reduction of 10 ml/kg or more i
n 48 hours had a significantly lower intact survival (10 of 28, 36%) t
han those with < 10 ml/kg or no reduction of ECW (15 of 22, 64%) (P <
0.05). The mortality was also higher in the former (7 of 28, 25%) than
in the latter (2 of 22, 9%), On multiple stepwise regression analysis
, ECW volume at admission (partial r(2) 0.20), ECW loss in 48 hours (p
artial r(2) 0.13) and plasma osmolality at admission (partial r(2) 0.2
2) were significantly related to outcome, We conclude that fluid restr
iction does not improve the outcome of acute meningitis, Indeed a decr
ease in ECW volume at 48 hours increases the likelihood of adverse out
come.